Ever since my colleague Neal brought his own homemade peanut butter to our office, I've been dying to make my own. There are so many great reasons to avoid commercially made peanut butter - chief among them that homemade tastes wayyyy better! Plus, most of us don't have time to make things from scratch and therefore have to sacrifice knowing exactly how our food is prepared and what's in it. I like that it's so easy to make such a staple food myself - I know exactly what's in it and under what conditions it was made. No salmonella here! Finally, it's insanely cheap to make.
I decided to try my first batch with a few thoughts in mind. I'm not a huge fan of having to stir the oil that usually sits at the top of natural peanut butter, and I know a ton of people who won't eat natural peanut butter because of this, so I wanted to make it as smooth and solid as possible. Coconut oil, in addition to being super good for you, is also solid at room temperature, so would theoretically help me achieve the consistency I was after. Just so you know, it's the partially hydrogenated oil added to commercial PB that keeps it solid but also makes it pretty bad for you (it turns into trans fats).
I also wanted to avoid using refined sugars, so I chose to sweeten mine with honey! Maple syrup seems like it would be another yummy option.
You can also avoid using oil altogether and just process the peanuts until they're nice and smooth - but the peanut butter will be a bit more difficult to spread.
You'll just need the ingredients below and a food processor!
Ingredients:
3 cups unsalted roasted peanuts
2 tbsps coconut oil - Try a different oil if you don't like a hint of coconut - safflower oil is another super healthy alternative that's tasteless.
Sea salt to taste
Honey to taste
A whopping 4 ingredients, plus my favorite measuring cups
Process peanuts one cup at a time; add coconut oil or oil of your choice as you go.
Once the peanut butter begins to get creamy, add salt and honey (or other sweetener) to taste.
Blend until it's as creamy as you'd like - mine took about 4-5 minutes. How simple is that?
Transfer the peanut butter to an airtight container, and you're done! The PB should last about a month, and up to two months if kept in the fridge.
I really like that this is completely customizable. For example, if you like chunky peanut butter, process one cup of peanuts until they're finely chopped, then set aside while you process the other two cups until creamy. Then mix the chopped peanuts in. You can also sweeten with other ingredients (like maple syrup) - my colleague Lib even suggested mixing in some Nutella!
This really is one of the easiest and most delicious things I've made in a long time - anyone can (and should) try it!